Cart 0

How to sell your old toys FAST!

Got old toys you no longer need? Whether they’re vintage collectibles or brand new, there are many ways to turn them into cash or find them a new home. Here are some tips on how to get started:

Donate Them

Consider donating to children's hospitals, daycares, or preschools. They often welcome toys in various conditions, and you might be eligible for a tax deduction.

Pawn Shops

For quick cash, a pawn shop can be an option, though expect lower offers. If you need cash immediately, this might be the fastest route.

eBay

Selling on eBay can bring in more money than a pawn shop, but it requires effort – listing, photographing, and shipping items, plus dealing with potential returns and fees. It’s effective, but time-consuming.

Selling a Large Collection?

Selling toys one by one can be a full-time job and take months. You’ll need to learn about toy values, take photos, list items, manage sales, and ship orders. It’s a lot of work!

Want a Better Option?

Get a great price and convenience by selling your toys to Emerald City Comics! We’ve made it simple with our “1-2-3” process:

  1. PREPARE YOUR COLLECTION:
    • Take clear photos of your toys, grouping similar items together.
  2. MAKE A QUICK LIST:
    • Write a brief overview of the toy lines and items. Avoid detailed inventories – just a general list unless we ask for more specifics.
  3. SEND US YOUR INFO:
    • Email your photos and list to toys@emeraldcitycomics.com or text 727-378-2410. We’ll follow up with any questions and let you know quickly if items aren’t of interest.

Why Use Our Method?

  • Save Time: Many toys don’t have a lot of collector value, and creating detailed lists can be a waste of effort. We can assess your collection’s potential quickly from a simple list and photos.
  • Targeted Requests: Instead of taking endless photos, we’ll only ask for additional ones if needed.

Ready to Sell Your Toys?

Here’s what happens next: once we’ve reviewed your collection, we’ll schedule an appointment for you to bring it in. Our experienced buyers will appraise it and make you an immediate cash or store credit offer – store credit offers a bit more value!

Why Sell to Us?

We’ve been buying and selling toys since 1989 and have earned a 4.8-star rating on Facebook and Google. Our buyers are experienced, fair, and respectful, understanding the sentimental and financial value of your collection.

Frequently Asked Question: “Why was I offered less than I expected?”

  • Condition Matters: Odors (such as smoke) and overall condition significantly impact value.
  • Retail Pricing: As a retail store, we can only offer a percentage of the retail, guide, or eBay value, since we need to cover operational costs and may hold onto items for extended periods.
  • Supply and Demand: If we have high supply or low demand for certain items, we might not be able to make an offer. In such cases, you may have better luck selling through eBay, Craigslist, or at a local convention; or consider donating to friends, family, or a charity.

Have questions?

Email toys@emeraldcitycomics.com or call 727-398-2665 and ask for Adam, Nick, or Dave. We’re here to help!